Forum Access Poll
Posted: 03 Nov 2013, 12:28
Events can sometimes dictate how the forums evolve. In light of recent events, we decided to take temporary action to prevent members having their posts misquoted, misinterpreted or taken out of context by any non-members.
So, to permanently resolve this issue, we have decided to create a poll for all members to cast their votes and we will abide by the result.
We have listed some points to consider for both the open-to-all and restricted access policies. You may also have your own reasons for your choice.
Points to consider for an Open Forum:
1. If unregistered users can see a lot of forums, it makes the board look more impressive and more inviting.
2. Members will not have to login to simply read a post that is currently in a restricted forum.
3. The 'Restricted' choice has come about because of the recent events which seems like a case of the tail wagging the dog??
4. For the past 13 years, the Open-to-all policy has always been the case on these forums and has been successful. Remember, this is just a Comics forum.
5. We're in danger of becoming a 'closed-shop' if we restrict access. Some people are quite happy to browse forums without being forced to sign up. These people may so mply stop visiting.
Points to consider for a Restricted Forum:
1. Unregistered users are made aware that there is more to read because it says so in the Forum Index - we can even state the names of the invisible forums
2. If you log in and visit any forum, it will automatically tell you if there are any new posts in the topics that interest you without you having to go into the individual topic and remember what you last read.
3. Registered users get a link to the first new post in every topic in each forum.
4. People will not pick up comments in the private forums via Google search
5. Users may feel safer and be more open if they know their comments in specified forums are not public
6. Former users who are currently prevented from posting will not be able to "spy" on the forums
7. The most popular forums (General and Non Comics Discussion) and the "public information" forums (Conventions and Reference section) remain open to the public
So, to permanently resolve this issue, we have decided to create a poll for all members to cast their votes and we will abide by the result.
We have listed some points to consider for both the open-to-all and restricted access policies. You may also have your own reasons for your choice.
Points to consider for an Open Forum:
1. If unregistered users can see a lot of forums, it makes the board look more impressive and more inviting.
2. Members will not have to login to simply read a post that is currently in a restricted forum.
3. The 'Restricted' choice has come about because of the recent events which seems like a case of the tail wagging the dog??
4. For the past 13 years, the Open-to-all policy has always been the case on these forums and has been successful. Remember, this is just a Comics forum.
5. We're in danger of becoming a 'closed-shop' if we restrict access. Some people are quite happy to browse forums without being forced to sign up. These people may so mply stop visiting.
Points to consider for a Restricted Forum:
1. Unregistered users are made aware that there is more to read because it says so in the Forum Index - we can even state the names of the invisible forums
2. If you log in and visit any forum, it will automatically tell you if there are any new posts in the topics that interest you without you having to go into the individual topic and remember what you last read.
3. Registered users get a link to the first new post in every topic in each forum.
4. People will not pick up comments in the private forums via Google search
5. Users may feel safer and be more open if they know their comments in specified forums are not public
6. Former users who are currently prevented from posting will not be able to "spy" on the forums
7. The most popular forums (General and Non Comics Discussion) and the "public information" forums (Conventions and Reference section) remain open to the public