Old Comic Mergers - What If?

Talk here about just about anything associated with British comics or story papers and the industry that does not fit in any other forum.
There are separate fora open to registered members for discussing specific comics, artists, websites etc.

Moderators: Al, AndyB

User avatar
SID
Posts: 1744
Joined: 02 Oct 2008, 22:53
Location: Mancave.
Contact:

Old Comic Mergers - What If?

Post by SID »

Nostalgia time! :)

Back in the day when comics came and went by the way of the "Exciting News Inside", was there ever a merger which you would have liked to have gone another way?

In my case, when Cracker merged with The Beezer back in the 70s, I lost a comic as I never liked The Beezer. Now if it had been merged with The Dandy, I would have still lost a comic but at least I would have the characters from my two favourite comics appearing in the same publication.
Last edited by SID on 19 Aug 2014, 20:47, edited 2 times in total.
Reading comics since 1970. My Current Regulars are: 2000 AD (1977-), Judge Dredd Megazine (1990-), Spaceship Away (2003-), Commando (2013-), Monster Fun (2022-), Deadpool and Wolverine (2023-), Quantum (2023-).

User avatar
Muffy
Posts: 343
Joined: 24 Jun 2007, 17:14

Re: Old Comic Mergers - What If?

Post by Muffy »

I would have loved to see Cheeky (as the headliner) incorporating Whizzer and Chips, with only 3 pages of Cheeky plus keeping Sweet Tooth, Joker, Junior Rotter, Superstore and others.

Alternatively IPC could have kept Monster Fun going (dropping Mickey Mouse earlier) and have had Wow! merge with it or even Scream! for an adventure + humour title (with 2 or 3 adventure strips along the lines of 'March of the Mighty Ones'). Later 'The Supernaturals' could have merged with it. In the early '70s it was not unusual to have a mix of adventure and humour (see early '70s issues of Buster)..
For reprints in the mid '80s they could have bought back some of Shiver and Shake stories.

User avatar
SID
Posts: 1744
Joined: 02 Oct 2008, 22:53
Location: Mancave.
Contact:

Re: Old Comic Mergers - What If?

Post by SID »

Monster Fun and Scream! - interesting combination.

Now I would have loved a Buster and Cheeky or even a Cheeky and Buster merger.
Reading comics since 1970. My Current Regulars are: 2000 AD (1977-), Judge Dredd Megazine (1990-), Spaceship Away (2003-), Commando (2013-), Monster Fun (2022-), Deadpool and Wolverine (2023-), Quantum (2023-).

User avatar
Digifiend
Posts: 7315
Joined: 15 Aug 2007, 11:43
Location: Hull, UK

Re: Old Comic Mergers - What If?

Post by Digifiend »

When Beezer and Topper folded, some of it's strips moved to Beano and Dandy but it didn't formally merge with either of the survivors (of course Blinky and the Numskulls are both Beezer strips but they ended up in different comics - something that couldn't happen if they properly merged - Blinky had to go to the Dandy though, as he was too similar to Erbert from Bash Street and therefore was unsuited to the Beano - Beryl probably went to Dandy for the same reason, being too similar to Minnie. Numskulls could've fitted in either comic). And more recently, The Beano took on Bananaman, the mini-strip concept, and the Madvertisements from the Dandy (and characters such as Nuke Noodle and Korky the Cat have made cameos on puzzle pages; they also took on the editorial staff). But again, no formal merger. That case is likely so that they didn't get backlash from the press for axing Desperate Dan.

User avatar
SID
Posts: 1744
Joined: 02 Oct 2008, 22:53
Location: Mancave.
Contact:

Re: Old Comic Mergers - What If?

Post by SID »

I still say that, considering what happened to The Dandy, it should have been merged with The Beano. That way more than just Bananaman would have survived. DCT could have kept the annuals separate but at least characters would have lived on in weekly form.

Now what would have happened if The Beano merged with The Dandy back when The Dandy had been the more popular? Would have the surviving Dandy been The Beano in all but name by 2014?
Reading comics since 1970. My Current Regulars are: 2000 AD (1977-), Judge Dredd Megazine (1990-), Spaceship Away (2003-), Commando (2013-), Monster Fun (2022-), Deadpool and Wolverine (2023-), Quantum (2023-).

User avatar
Digifiend
Posts: 7315
Joined: 15 Aug 2007, 11:43
Location: Hull, UK

Re: Old Comic Mergers - What If?

Post by Digifiend »

They way they did it did avoid negative press though. If they merged but didn't carry over Dan, it would've caused a backlash. As it was, any press they got was simply about how sad it was that the Dandy was closing after 75 years. The digital Dandy's launch and failure was all but ignored by other media.

User avatar
SID
Posts: 1744
Joined: 02 Oct 2008, 22:53
Location: Mancave.
Contact:

Re: Old Comic Mergers - What If?

Post by SID »

Digifiend wrote:They way they did it did avoid negative press though. If they merged but didn't carry over Dan, it would've caused a backlash. As it was, any press they got was simply about how sad it was that the Dandy was closing after 75 years. The digital Dandy's launch and failure was all but ignored by other media.
But why wouldn't they want to carry over Dan? He is still a marketable and popular character so it doesn't make sense.
Reading comics since 1970. My Current Regulars are: 2000 AD (1977-), Judge Dredd Megazine (1990-), Spaceship Away (2003-), Commando (2013-), Monster Fun (2022-), Deadpool and Wolverine (2023-), Quantum (2023-).

User avatar
Digifiend
Posts: 7315
Joined: 15 Aug 2007, 11:43
Location: Hull, UK

Re: Old Comic Mergers - What If?

Post by Digifiend »

Don't know, but for some reason they didn't. Maybe they were hoping that the Dandy could be somehow revived... but it's now been a year since the digital comic was cancelled. I think the ship has sailed and summer specials and annuals will be it's future now.

As for the merger topic, here's another suggestion: What if Plug, being based on a Beano character, had merged with that instead of the Beezer?

User avatar
dishes
Posts: 341
Joined: 29 Jun 2010, 09:12

Re: Old Comic Mergers - What If?

Post by dishes »

SID wrote: Now what would have happened if The Beano merged with The Dandy back when The Dandy had been the more popular? Would have the surviving Dandy been The Beano in all but name by 2014?
I doubt it. Firstly, Albert Barnes was a very different editor to George Moonie, so it's doubtful that Dennis the Menace would have been created under his editorship. And of course that strip was the catalyst for the change of tone and the creation of all the other classic '50s and early '60s characters.

Secondly, I suspect the Dandy wouldn't even have survived as long as it did without the Beano providing a competitive spur, and an example to follow when it (the Dandy) began to lose ground. Unless there was a similar rival comic to provide such a spur. (Hope I don't sound like some free-marketeer here).

geoff42
Posts: 671
Joined: 18 Apr 2014, 00:48

Re: Old Comic Mergers - What If?

Post by geoff42 »

what if Warlord had joined with Battle? I know... two separate publishers and all that... but just think, if they could have come to some resolution - who knows. Marvel and DC have merged now and then (albeit with a mini series). Warlord sank eventually without trace whereas Battle was swamped with toys merchandise in its latter days before skulking into the wings of an ailing "Eagle". It could have been interesting.

Lew Stringer
Posts: 7041
Joined: 01 Mar 2006, 00:59
Contact:

Re: Old Comic Mergers - What If?

Post by Lew Stringer »

geoff42 wrote:what if Warlord had joined with Battle? I know... two separate publishers and all that... but just think, if they could have come to some resolution - who knows. Marvel and DC have merged now and then (albeit with a mini series). Warlord sank eventually without trace whereas Battle was swamped with toys merchandise in its latter days before skulking into the wings of an ailing "Eagle". It could have been interesting.
Well Battle was revamped with Action Force, then Storm Force, and then non-war stories because war comics were becoming unpopular. So merging Warlord into Battle and keeping it as a war comic wouldn't have halted the decline in readers.
The blog of British comics: http://lewstringer.blogspot.com
My website: http://www.lewstringer.com
Blog about my own work: http://lewstringercomics.blogspot.com/

User avatar
Old Freddy
Posts: 197
Joined: 11 Jun 2009, 19:51
Location: In front of the computer

Re: Old Comic Mergers - What If?

Post by Old Freddy »

Digifiend wrote:When Beezer and Topper folded, some of it's strips moved to Beano and Dandy but it didn't formally merge with either of the survivors (of course Blinky and the Numskulls are both Beezer strips but they ended up in different comics - something that couldn't happen if they properly merged - Blinky had to go to the Dandy though, as he was too similar to Erbert from Bash Street and therefore was unsuited to the Beano - Beryl probably went to Dandy for the same reason, being too similar to Minnie. Numskulls could've fitted in either comic). And more recently, The Beano took on Bananaman, the mini-strip concept, and the Madvertisements from the Dandy (and characters such as Nuke Noodle and Korky the Cat have made cameos on puzzle pages; they also took on the editorial staff). But again, no formal merger. That case is likely so that they didn't get backlash from the press for axing Desperate Dan.
I do think that the move not to The Dandy with The Beano was a bit of a waste. It's a great shame that all those great characters created between 2010-2012 never found themselves a new home; The Dandy annuals mostly use retro characters and the Summer Specials are all reprint (though if next year's one does have new material, I do hope that they can get some post-2010 characters in there).

Having The Beezer and Topper merge with The Dandy could have been a good idea, though having different characters distributed across both The Dandy and The Beano was probably a better decision. (and the name "The Dandy and The Beezer and Topper" sounds a bit silly) However, now that I have read some issues of The Beezer and Topper, I think it would have been better if more characters survived. More specifically, the characters conceived during the merged comic's lifetime. All of the surviving characters (with the exception of Potsworth & Co) existed prior to the merger (that includes Blinky as he was just a de-aged Colonel Blink) and Beryl was the only one to immediately transfer (all the others had to wait a few months or so) and The Beezer Annuals tended to just use pre-merger characters (and rarely any Topper characters). I think Fairy Grotto was an interesting strip that could have probably benefited from transferring to The Beano or The Dandy (although My Own Genie arguably pulled off a similar concept far better), Pxqztkle would have probably been quite at home in The Dandy, and I'd have liked to see "Ghost!" continue into one of the comics (The fact that he was brought back several years later as "Hector Spectre" implies that he was a popular enough character.) It's possible that they were planning to keep these characters alive by continuing the Topper annual, but unfortunately such a thing never happened either way.
Last update to http://comiccentral.jimdo.com: 7/4/2011

Sammy Shrink, Korky, Dennis and the Dandy all updated
Beryl the Peril Page Added
Navigation altered

big bad bri
Posts: 1761
Joined: 03 Mar 2006, 15:50

Re: Old Comic Mergers - What If?

Post by big bad bri »

Having The Beezer and Topper merge with The Dandy could have been a good idea, though having different characters distributed across both The Dandy and The Beano was probably a better decision. (and the name "The Dandy and The Beezer and Topper" sounds a bit silly) .

I suppose they could have called it Dandy WITH Beezer & Topper like Buster did when whizzer & chips merged with it.

User avatar
starscape
Posts: 989
Joined: 17 Jul 2011, 14:51
Location: UK
Contact:

Re: Old Comic Mergers - What If?

Post by starscape »

Maybe Warlord with The Crunch might have prolonged their lives a little. It would have moved Warlord away from strictly WW2, bringing in aspects such as sci-fi. Of course, that may have tuned Warlord readers off. Who knows but I would have loved to have read it.
STARSCAPE Comic
http://facebook.com/Starscape-Comic-108831387707862/
comics, cartoons, music & movies

User avatar
SID
Posts: 1744
Joined: 02 Oct 2008, 22:53
Location: Mancave.
Contact:

Re: Old Comic Mergers - What If?

Post by SID »

starscape wrote:Maybe Warlord with The Crunch might have prolonged their lives a little. It would have moved Warlord away from strictly WW2, bringing in aspects such as sci-fi. Of course, that may have tuned Warlord readers off. Who knows but I would have loved to have read it.
Or better still, The Crunch and Warlord.
Reading comics since 1970. My Current Regulars are: 2000 AD (1977-), Judge Dredd Megazine (1990-), Spaceship Away (2003-), Commando (2013-), Monster Fun (2022-), Deadpool and Wolverine (2023-), Quantum (2023-).

Post Reply